My sister and her fiance had their engagement dinner here and it was ok. The pizza was fine, but by far not the best I've ever had. I felt that it was quite loud and hard to carry on a converstation with everyone at the table due to the excessive noise coming from the rest of the restaurant. All in all, I'd go back if invited by others, but would not make reservations for myself.
With 4 Louisville locations, you can't go wrong with Wick's. It is homemade pizza and yummy! It won Louisville Magazine Best of Louisville Award 4 years in a row! They offer the Big Wick pizza, which is huge, but also have great sandwiches and desserts to. The dinign atmosphere if fun, but carryout and delivery are avl. as well!